LINGUISTIC SITUATION IN KAZAKHSTAN: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE SOVIET AND INDEPENDENCE PERIODS
https://doi.org/10.55491/2411-6076-2024-4-116-134
Abstract
The article examines the typological features of the linguistic situation in the Soviet and independence periods, the number of ethno-linguistic structures in the linguistic environment, the level of ethnolinguistic diversity, the share of the population speaking each language, the demographic potential of linguistic structures, the functions performed by each linguistic structure concerning the total number of communicative services, as well as the comparative communicative capacity of linguistic structures and their legal status. In other words, the nature of state regulation of the ratio of languages, the level of genetic proximity of the languages that make up the linguistic situation, the ethnic origin of the prestigious language in the current linguistic situation, and the assessment of the languages jointly used by society are analyzed. It should be noted that the Soviet period in the article refers to the twenty-year period before the year of independence. Relevance of the article: due to the multi-ethnic structure and cultural diversity of Kazakhstan, language policy affects not only the country's social stability and economic development but also cultural integration (). Since gaining independence, changes in language policy and the analysis of the current linguistic situation have become especially relevant. Novelty: the study presents the transformation of the linguistic situation in Kazakhstan by comparing the language policy of the Soviet period and its long-term consequences with the period of independence. New trends and tendencies are identified, new sources are analyzed, including recent studies and statistical data. The sociolinguistic characteristics of the current linguistic situation are assessed, the role of the Kazakh language is examined, and possible directions for its further development are predicted. Practical significance: the results of the study can be useful to scientists and specialists in the field of language policy, sociolinguists, sociologists, and political scientists to improve the language policy of the Republic of Kazakhstan, develop intercultural communication, and support multilingualism. In addition, the study provides an opportunity to develop practical recommendations for the implementation of language policy in the education system and in the field of culture.
Keywords
About the Authors
А. FazylzhanovaKazakhstan
Anar Fazylzhanova, Candidate of Philological Sciences
Almaty
А. Piyazbayeva
Kazakhstan
Akmaral Piyazbayeva, Corresponding author, doctoral student
Almaty
References
1. Abylhozhin, Zh.B., Kozybaev, M.K., Tatimov, M.B. (1989) Kazahstanskaja tragedija. Voprosy istorii. No. 7. S. 53- 71 [Abylhozhin, Zh.B., Kozybayev, M.K., Tatimov, M.B. (1989) The Tragedy of Kazakhstan. Questions of History. No. 7. P. 53-71.] (in Russian)
2. Alekseenko, A. (2008) Immigracija v Kazahstane (1999-2005 gg.). CAMMIC Working Papers. No. 3 S. 2-9. [Alexeyenko, A. (2008) Immigration in Kazakhstan (1999-2005). CAMMIC Working Papers No.3. P. 2-9.] (in Russian)
3. Alekseenko, A. (2000) Kazahstan v zerkale perepisej naselenija. Naselenie i obshhestvo. Informacionnyj bjulleten' Centra demografii i jekologii cheloveka Instituta narodnohozjajstvennogo prognozirovanija RAN. Moskva, No. 47. [Alexeyenko, A. (2000) Kazakhstan in the Mirror of Population Censuses. Population and Society. Information Bulletin of the Center for Demography and Human Ecology of the Institute of National Economic Forecasting, RAS. Moscow, No. 47.] (in Russian)
4. Aleumettіk lingvistika terminderіnіng sozdіgі. Slovar' sociolingvisticheskih terminov (2020). 2-basylymy, ongdelgen / Sulejmenova Je.D., Shajmerdenova N.Zh., Smagulova Zh.S., Aqanova D.H. Almaty. 400 b. [Dictionary of Sociolinguistic Terms (2020). 2nd Edition, Revised / Edited by S. Suleimenova, N. Zhaimerdenova, Zh. Smagulova, D. Akanova. Almaty. 400 p.] (in Kazakh)
5. Alpatov, V.M. (2000) 150 jazykov i politika. 1917-2000. Sociolingvisticheskie problemy SSSR i postsovetskogo prostranstva. 2-e izd. Moskva: KRAFT, IV RAN, 224 s. [Alpatov, V.M. (2000) 150 Languages and Politics. 1917–2000. Sociolinguistic Problems of the USSR and Post-Soviet Space. 2nd ed. Moscow: KRAFT, IV RAN, 224 p.] (in Russian)
6. Belikov, V.I. (1997) Nadezhnost' sovetskih jetnodemograficheskih dannyh. Malye jazyki Evrazii: sociolingvisticheskij aspekt. Moskva: MGU, 43 s. [Belikov, V. I. (1997) Reliability of Soviet Ethnodemographic Data. Minority Languages of Eurasia: Sociolinguistic Aspect. Moscow: Moscow State University, 43 p.] (in Russian)
7. Bodauhan, Q., Sadvaqasova, A. (2020) Qazaqstanda іshkі koshі-qon urdіsіn ujlestіru maselelerі. «Sejfullin oqulary – 16: Zhanga formacijadagy zhastar – gylymi qazaqstannyng bolashagy» atty halyqaralyq gylymi-teorijalyq konferencijasynyng materialdary. T.І, Ch.2 B. 140-144. [Bodaukhan, K., & Sadvakasova, A. (2020) Issues of Coordinating Internal Migration in Kazakhstan. Materials of the International Scientific and Theoretical Conference “Seifullin Readings – 16: Youth of the New Formation – the Scientific Future of Kazakhstan”. Vol. I. Part 2. P. 140-144.] (in Kazakh)
8. Drobizheva, L., Gettemjuller, R., Kelleher, K. (1998) Jetnicheskij konflikt v postsovetskom mire: tematicheskie issledovanija i analiz. Moskva. 365 s. [Drobizheva, L., Gettemuller, R., & Kelleher, K. (1998) Ethnic Conflict in the PostSoviet World: Thematic Research and Analysis. Moscow. 365 p.] (in Russian)
9. Fazylzhanova, A.M. (2020) Qazaq zhazuyn zhanggyrtudyng aleumettіk tіltanymdyq negіzderі (tіldіk zhagdajat zhane tauekelderdі basqaru). Almaty: El-shezhіre, 220 b. [Fazylzhanova, A.M. (2020) Sociolinguistic Foundations for the Modernization of the Kazakh Script (Language Situation and Risk Management). Almaty: El-Shezhire, 220 p.] (in Kazakh)
10. Földes, C. Zur Begrifflichkeit von “Sprachenkontakt” und “Sprachenmischung”. Lasatowicz, Maria Katarzyna/Joachimsthaler, Jürgen (Hrsg.) (1999) Assimilation – Abgrenzung Austausch. Interkulturalität in Sprache und Literatur. Frankfurt a.M., Berlin, Bern, Bruxelles, New York, Wien: Lang. Oppelner Beiträge zur Germanistik, Bd. 1. (in German)
11. Golod v kazahskoj stepi: (Pis'ma trevogi i boli) (1991). Sost.: Abdirajymov S., Buhonova, I.N., Gribanova, E.M. i dr. Alma-Ata: Qazaq universitetі, 208 s. [Hunger in the Kazakh Steppe: (Letters of Anxiety and Pain) (1991). Compiled by: Abdirayimov S., Bukhonova, I.N., Gribanova, E.M., et al. Almaty: Kazakh University, 208 p.] (in Russian)
12. Kobenko, Ju.V. (2010) Teorija jekzoglossii. Nacional'nyj issledovatel'skij Tomskij politehnicheskij universitet. Tomsk: Izd-vo Tomskogo politehnicheskogo universiteta, 135 s. [Kobenko, Yu.V. (2010) Theory of Exoglossy. National Research Tomsk Polytechnic University. Tomsk: Publishing House of Tomsk Polytechnic University, 135 p.] (in Russian)
13. Kozina, V.V. (2007) Demograficheskaja istorija Kazahstana (konec H1H – nach. HH1 vv.): ucheb.pos. Karaganda: Izd-vo KarGU. [Kozina, V.V. (2007) Demographic History of Kazakhstan (late 19th – early 21st centuries). Karaganda: Publishing House of Karaganda State University.] (in Russian)
14. Mechkovskaja, N.B. (2001) Obshhee jazykoznanie: Strukturnaja i social'naja tipologija jazykov: uchebnoe posobie dlja studentov filologicheskih i lingvisticheskih special'nostej. 2-e izd. Moskva: Flinta: Nauka, 312 s. [Mechkovskaya, N.B. (2001) General Linguistics: Structural and Social Typology of Languages: A Textbook for Students of Philology and Linguistics. 2nd ed. Moscow: FLINTA: Nauka, 312 p.] (in Russian)
15. Naselenie SSSR: Po dannym Vsesojuznoj perepisi naselenija 1979 goda (1980). Moskva: Politizdat, 31 s. [Population of the USSR: Based on the All-Union Population Census of 1979 (1980). Moscow: Politizdat, 31 p.] (in Russian)
16. Nasil'stvennaja kollektivizacija i golod v Kazahstane v 1931-33 gg. Sbornik dokumentov i materialov. Almaty: «Fond HH1 vek. Sost.: Aldazhumanov K.S., Kairgaliev M.K., Osipov V.P., Romanov Ju.I.; Redkol.: Kozybaev M.K. (gl. red.) i dr.; AN Resp. Kazahstan. In-t istorii i jetnologii im. Ch.Ch. Valihanova, Arh. Prezidenta Resp. Kazahstan, Centr. gos. arh. Resp. Kazahstan. Almaty, 1998. 263 s. [Forced Collectivization and Hunger in Kazakhstan in 1931-33. Collection of Documents and Materials. Almaty: “21st Century Fund”. Compiled by: K. S. Aldazhumanov, M.K. Kairgaliyev, V.P. Osipov, Yu.I. Romanov; Editorial Board: M.K. Kozybayev (Editor-in-Chief) et al.; Institute of History and Ethnology named after Ch.Ch. Valikhanov, Archive of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Almaty, 1998. 263 p.] (in Russian)
17. Qazaqstan Respublikasyndagy ulttyq quramy, dіni nanymy zhane tіlderdі menggeruі (2023) / qazaq zhane orys tіlderіnde / 541 bet. (jelektrondy resurs) URL:https://stat.gov.kz/upload/iblock/107/5zkn34tqn5atonvbhoob28p7ebnrbc19 /Nacional'nyj%20sostav,%20veroispovedanie%20i%20vladenie%20jazykami%20v%20RK.pdf [National Composition, Religious Beliefs, and Language Proficiency in the Republic of Kazakhstan (2023) / In Kazakh and Russian languages. 541 p. URL:https://stat.gov.kz/upload/iblock/107/5zkn34tqn5atonvbhoob28p7ebnrbc19/Nacional'nyj%20sostav,%20veroispove dan ie%20i%20vladenie%20jazykami%20v%20RK.pdf] (in Kazakh)
18. Rossija i sovremennyj mir (1999). Vypusk 1. INION RAN. 133 s. [Russia and the Modern World (1999). Issue 1. INION RAS. 133 p.] (in Russian)
19. Shvejcer, A.D., Nikol'skij, L.B. (1978) Vvedenie v sociolingvistiku. Moskva: Vysshaja shkola, 216 s. [Schweitzer, A.D., & Nikolsky, L.B. (1978) Introduction to Sociolinguistics. Moscow: Higher School, 216 p.] (in Russian)
20. Slovar' sociolingvisticheskih terminov (2002) / Sulejmenova Je.D., Shajmerdenova N.Zh.; Kazah. nac. un-t im. Al'- Farabi. Almaty: Qazaq universiteti. 168 s. ISBN 9965-12-165-6 [Dictionary of Sociolinguistic Terms (2002) / Edited by E.D. Suleimenova, N.Zh. Shaimerdenova; Kazakh National University named after Al-Farabi. Almaty: Kazakh University. 168 p. ISBN 9965-12-165-6] (in Russian)
21. Slovar' sociolingvisticheskih terminov (2006). Moskva: Institut jazykoznanija RAN, 312 s. [Dictionary of Sociolinguistic Terms (2006). Moscow: Institute of Linguistics RAS, 312 p.] (in Russian)
22. Smajylov A.A. (2010) 2009 Zhylgy Qazaqstan Respublikasy halyq sanagy. Qysqasha qorytyndylar. Statistikalyq zhinaq. Astana. 110 b. [Smaiylov, A.A. (2010) The 2009 Population Census of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Summary Results. Statistical Collection. Astana. 110 p.] (in Kazakh)
23. Sulejmenova, Je.D. (2009) Ocherk jazykovoj politiki i jazykovoj situacii v Kazahstane. Russian Language Journal. Vol. 59 Issue 1. S. 21-36. [Suleimenova, E.D. (2009) Essay on Language Policy and Language Situation in Kazakhstan. Russian Language Journal. Vol. 59, Issue 1. P. 21-36.] (in Russian)
24. Sulejmenova, Je.D., Akanova, D.H., Ajmagambetova, M.M. (2021) Biz birgemiz, ili Eshhe raz o diversifikacii russkogo jazyka v Kazahstane. Vestnik RUDN. Serija: Teorija jazyka. Semiotika. Semantika. Tom.12. No.1. [Suleimenova, E.D., Akanova, D.K., & Aimagambetova, M.M. (2021) "Biz birgemiz" or Another Look at the Diversification of the Russian Language in Kazakhstan. Bulletin of the RUDN University. Series: Language Theory. Semiotics. Semantics. Vol. 12. No.1.] (in Russian)
25. Sulejmenova, Je.D. (2016) Vybor jazyka i korreljacii jazykovoj transmissii: monografija / Almaty: Qazaq universitetі. 184 s. [Suleimenova, E.D. (2016) Language Choice and Correlations of Language Transmission: A Monograph. Almaty: Kazakh University. 184 p.] (in Russian)
26. Sulejmenova, Je.D. (2018) Jazyk kak resurs mjagkoj sily: monografija / Kazahskij nac. un-t im. Al'-Farabi. 2-e izd., dop.. Almaty: Qazaq universitetі, S. 109-115. [Suleimenova, E.D. (2018) Language as a Resource of Soft Power: A Monograph / Kazakh National University named after Al-Farabi. 2nd ed., supplemented. Almaty: Kazakh University, P. 109-115.] (in Russian)
27. Temirova, D.M. (2010) Dinamika izmenenija jazykovoj situacii v Respublike Kazahstan. Vestnik KazNU. Serija filologicheskaja, №4-5 (128-129). S. 167-170. [Temirova, D.M. (2010) Dynamics of Changes in the Language Situation in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Bulletin of KazNU. Philological Series, No. 4-5 (128-129). P. 167-170.] (in Russian)
28. Ualiuly, N. (2008) Orys tіlіnіng turmany tugel. Ana tіlі. No. 9. [Ualіuly, N. (2008) All Elements of the Russian Language Are Intact. Ana Tili. No. 9.] (in Kazakh)
29. Ulttyq statistika bjurosy Qazaqstan Respublikasy Strategijalyq zhosparlau zhane reformalar agenttіgі. 2021 zhylgy ulttyq halyq sanagynyng qorytyndylary (jelektrondy resurs) https://stat.gov.kz/national/2021/ [Bureau of National Statisticsof the Republic of Kazakhstan Strategic Planning and Reforms Agency. Results of the 2021 National Population Census. URLhttps://stat.gov.kz/national/2021/] (in Kazakh)
30. Zhiromskaja, V.B. (1991) Vsesojuznaja perepis' naselenija 1937 g.: Kratkie itogi. Moskva: Institut istorii SSSR AN SSSR, 239 s. [Zhiromskaya, V.B. (1991) All-Union Population Census of 1937: Brief Results. Moscow: Institute of History of the USSR, Academy of Sciences of the USSR, 239 p.] (in Russian)
31. Zhyl sajyn auyldan qalaga 200 myng qazaqstandyq koshedі – UJeM (2023). Halyq Uni jelektrondy portaly (jelektrondy resurs) https://halyq-uni.kz/news/15581-zhyl-saiyn-auyldan-kalaga-200-myn-kazakstandyk-koshedi-uem/ [Every Year, 200 Thousand Kazakhstanis Move from Villages to Cities – NEA (2023). Halyq Uni Electronic Portal. URL https://halyq-uni.kz/news/15581-zhyl-saiyn-auyldan-kalaga-200-myn-kazakstandyk-koshedi-uem/] (in Kazakh)
Review
For citations:
Fazylzhanova А., Piyazbayeva А. LINGUISTIC SITUATION IN KAZAKHSTAN: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE SOVIET AND INDEPENDENCE PERIODS. Tiltanym. 2024;96(4):116-134. (In Kazakh) https://doi.org/10.55491/2411-6076-2024-4-116-134